PHI 271: PRESENTATION
PEER CRITIQUE FORM
Department of
Philosophy
PresenterŐs Name:_____________________________________________________________________
Topic:______________________________________________________________
Date:____________
Name of Evaluator:____________________________________________________________________
Please evaluate the presenter on
each of the following competencies.
For each competency, enter a score in the corresponding blank space in
the last column based on the following scale:
0 = Poor,
1 = Fair, 2 = Good, 3
= Average, 4 = Very Good, 5 = Excellent
|
STRUCTURE |
COMPETENCIES (LEARNING OUTCOMES) |
SCORE |
|||
|
INTRODUCTION |
Introduced self &
presentation topic |
|
|||
|
BODY |
Problem/Need
Identification |
Identified a specific
problem to be solved or need to be met |
|
||
|
Formulated coherent, valid
philosophical arguments |
|
||||
|
Noted strength/weakness of
the problem/project |
|
||||
|
Compared competing
philosophical ideas of the project |
|
||||
|
Presented a
position/standpoint on the problem/project |
|
||||
|
Organization |
Presented ideas in logical
sequence |
|
|||
|
Used words to jog memory
instead of reading from text |
|
||||
|
Evaluation |
Evaluated adequacy of
information (current, relevant, etc.) |
|
|||
|
Documented sources of
information or data |
|
||||
|
Visuals Aids |
Used appropriate visual
aids (graphs, tables, charts, etc.) |
|
|||
|
Knows well how to operate
presentation equipment & tools |
|
||||
|
Verbal Delivery |
Used a safe & inclusive
language for audience diversity |
|
|||
|
Used effective transitions
to bridge main points |
|
||||
|
Nonverbal Delivery |
Used appropriate vocal
qualities (volume, rate, variety, etc.) |
|
|||
|
Maintained adequate eye
contact with audience members |
|
||||
|
Timeliness |
Began the presentation on
time |
|
|||
|
Delivered the presentation
within allotted time |
|
||||
|
CONCLUSION |
Summarized what the
audience needs to know, believe, or do |
|
|||
|
|
|
||||
|
Invited questions from the
audience at the end of the presentation |
|
||||
|
|
TOTAL SCORE |
|
|||
|
GRADE SCALE |
A+ = 97-100; A = 94-96; A- = 90-93; B+ = 87-89; B = 84-86;
B- = 80-83; |
|
|||
|
C+ = 77-79; C = 74-76; C- = 70-73; D+ = 67-69; D = 64-66; D- = 60-63; E = 0-59 |
|||||